solution finder

27 April 2018

Vacuum Toilet

Author/Compiled by
Beat Stauffer (seecon international gmbh)
Executive Summary

Vacuum toilets are flush toilets that use suction for the removal of faeces and urine resulting in a minimal requirement of water (0.5 to 1.5 litres). Vacuum toilets provide the same level of comfort as traditional flush toilets and they help saving costs due to the minimised amount of flush water. Due to the fact that the effluent has a high organic matter content, vacuum toilets are specifically adapted for the use in combination with separate greywater and blackwater treatment; or aerobic digestion treatment for biogas production. Vacuum toilet systems are applicable both in large and small buildings, trains, ships and airplanes.

Advantages
Large water savings
No deposits in the toilet, reduced use of detergents
Very hygienic
Flexible and convenient
No deposits in the pipes
Odour-free
Facilitates reuse of urine and faeces
Applicable in many different constructions
Disadvantages
Relatively high investment cost
Depended on electric power supply
Coarse materials can lead to blockage of collection system
House service connection and vacuum station have to be maintained
Need for a vacuum station (house-or community based)
Requires space for connection
Bulky material (i.e. sanitary napkins) can lead to clogging
In Out

(Freshwater), Blackwater, Faecal Sludge, Greywater, Brownwater, Urine or Yellowwater, Faeces, Excreta, Energy

Blackwater, Faecal Sludge

Factsheet Block Title
Introduction
Factsheet Block Body

The use of vacuum toilets provides a similar level of comfort as traditional flush toilets, but they use much less water due to air sucked into the toilet when flushing, thereby producing a vacuum. This results in a minimal requirement of water (0.5 to 1.5 litres) for the transport of faeces and urine (WHO 2006; ROEVAC 2011). The system is completely closed. Is there a leak, the negative pressure in the pipes reduces the risk of raw sewage spill (see also vacuum sewers) (WHO 2006). Vacuum toilets can be installed in single households, hotels, or whole communities and are also adapted for train, ships or airplanes. Due to the fact that the effluent has a high organic matter content, vacuum toilets are specifically adapted for the use in combination with separate greywater and blackwater treatment; or aerobic digestion treatment for biogas production. To minimise the water consumption of a vacuum toilet even more, urine diversion bowls can be applied (learn more about it: urine diversion components).

Factsheet Block Title
Basic Design Principles
Factsheet Block Body

Basically, there are two different designs for a vacuum toilet system: The constant vacuum system (CVS) and the vacuum on demand (VOD) system. Which one will be applied depends on specific framework conditions.

Factsheet Block Title
Constant Vacuum System (CVS)
Factsheet Block Body

   System design example with various discharge options. Source: JETSGROUP (2009)

System design example with various discharge options. Source: JETSGROUP (2009)   

This is the better solution for larger buildings. Virtually, it is possible to add an unlimited number of toilets and the system can be expanded later on. If there is a permanent vacuum, the risk of a leakage is very low (JETSGROUP 2011). However, energy requirement are generally high in order to maintain the vacuum constantly. It depends on the manufacturer, but normally a constant vacuum system functions as follows (adapted from ROEVAC 2011)

Step 1: The user pushes the push-button, the interface valve is opened and the wastewater is evacuated. Air, which also helps to transport the waste, is also sucked into the system. At the same time, the clean water valve is opened and rinsing water is sprayed into the bowl.

Step 2: The vacuum valve is closed but the water valve remains open. A small amount of fresh water is sprayed into the bowl.

Step 3: The water valve is closed, a small volume of clean water is retained in the bowl and the toilet is ready for use again.

The collected blackwater can be discharged in different ways (JETSGROUP 2011):

Vacuum toilets systems are very favourable for source separation. In this case, greywater is collected in “greywater interface units” and is soaked away as soon as it is filled up.

Factsheet Block Title
Vacuum On Demand (VOD)
Factsheet Block Body

(adapted from JETSGROUP 2005)

             

Jets vacuum toilet (VOD) and its components. Source: JETSGROUP (2005)              

Vacuum on demand systems produce a vacuum only at the moment the toilet needs to be flushed. The system also uses air together with water for transport of sewage, as opposed to conventional flush toilets, which use water only. The VOD toilet evacuates air from the drainpipes automatically upon activation of the activator button. A valve opens in the toilet, and the difference in air pressure that results causes the sewage to be flushed.Due to lower energy requirement, small VOD systems can be solar powered.


At the end of the vacuum pipes, “biotanks” can be made available to compost the already shredded waste on-site. Flushed sewage is pumped through a particle filter into the composting tank. As soon as it is full, it can be emptied and put aside for further composting (see also small-scale or large-scale co-composting. The liquid, which is collected at the bottom of the tank, can be infiltrated or used as fertiliser (see also leach field, soak pit, fertigation) (JETSGROUP 2005). Depending on the local standards and restrictions a secondary treatment may be required before discharge or reuse (see also non-planted filters; vertical, horizontal or free surface-flow constructed wetlands.

                  The VOC toilet system in combination with on-site sewage treatment. Source JETSGROUP (2005)

The VOC toilet system in combination with on-site sewage treatment. Source JETSGROUP (2005)                  


Factsheet Block Title
Costs Considerations
Factsheet Block Body

As it is a high-tech system, it is expensive. But in comparison with a common flush-toilet system, it can be slightly cheaper, because piping costs are lower (the dimensions are smaller, 50 to 75 mm) and a on-site treatment system can be more easily installed. Also the installation can be cheaper because piping is independent from the building structure. Vacuum lines may be installed vertically into the suspended ceiling as waste can be lifted.

Factsheet Block Title
Operation and Maintenance
Factsheet Block Body

The in-house installations require little maintenance and are easy to clean. The suction effect increases hygiene and reduces odour (HEEB et al. 2007). If a composting tank is used, it has to be emptied and cleaned periodically to avoid an overflow. If there are any problems with the technical components, such as valves or pipes, the manufacturer has to be contacted.

Factsheet Block Title
Health Aspects
Factsheet Block Body

A vacuum toilet system guarantees a high level of comfort and hygiene. As long as the toilet is kept clean, there are absolutely no hazards. When composting such products, special care should be taken as the associated health risk is higher than for common kitchen waste.

Factsheet Block Title
At a Glance
Factsheet Block Body

Working Principle

Vacuum toilets are flush toilets that use a negative pressure (vacuum) to suck faeces away.

Capacity/Adequacy

A vacuum toilet system is designed for small cottage, large buildings and even trains, ships and planes.

Performance

If it is designed and constructed correctly performance is very reliable.

Costs

Costs are lower in comparison with a common flush-system

Self-help Compatibility

Low. Requires Installations through professionals. However, through the fact that pipes are much more flexible than conventional sewage pipes, and can be laid at a more shallow depth, reparations are easier than with other systems.

O&M

In-house installations are easy to clan and require little maintenance. Technical components should be maintained by professionals only.

Reliability

Very reliable.

Main strength

Saving significant quantities of water (only 0.5 to 1 litre required per flush) and allows a large flexibility for on-site treatment (independent of large sewer collection systems).

Main weakness

High costs and it needs expert design

Applicability

Vacuum technology for sanitary installations is an advanced technique in both economic and ecologic aspects. Its application is flexible and independent from a (natural) slope. New buildings as well as the sanitation of old buildings or the reconstruction of existing buildings are all appropriate fields of application. Vacuum sanitation systems are preferably used in buildings where the wastewater flow is high or varies greatly (hotels, restaurants, motorway services areas, airports, railway stations etc.), in bigger building complexes and in commercial and industrial halls, where the sanitary installations are often located at remote distances (adapted from ROEVAC 2011). Vacuum toilets are also a convenient solution for decentralised wastewater treatment. Effluents, such as urine and faeces can be treated by a biogas settler or a biotank with a following small scale composting attachment.

Library References

Guidelines for the safe use of wastewater excreta and greywater. Volume IV. Excreta and Greywater Use in Agriculture

Volume IV of the Guidelines for the Safe Use of Wastewater, Excreta and Greywater recognizes the reuse potential of wastewater and excreta (including urine) in agriculture and describes the present state of knowledge as regards potential health risks associated with the reuse as well as measures to manage these health risks following a multi-barrier approach.

WHO (2006): Guidelines for the safe use of wastewater excreta and greywater. Volume IV. Excreta and Greywater Use in Agriculture, Geneva: World Health Organisation URL [Accessed: 31.05.2018] PDF
Further Readings

How to Manage Public Toilets and Showers

The purpose of this decision-making aid is to provide practical advice and recommendations for managing toilet blocks situated in public places. It is primarily aimed at local decision-makers in developing countries and at their partners (project planners and managers).

TOUBKISS, J. ; (2010): How to Manage Public Toilets and Showers, (= Six Methodological Guides for a Water and Sanitation Services' Development Strategy , 5 ). Cotonou and Paris: Partenariat pour le Développement Municipal (PDM) and Programme Solidarité Eau (pS-Eau) URL [Accessed: 19.10.2011]
Case Studies

Urine Diversion Vacuum Sanitation System

Case study about an alternative sanitation system for urban buildings. A vacuum urine-diverting sewerage system is used to reduce potable water consumption and to reduce wastewater production.

GERMER, J. SuSanA (2009): Urine Diversion Vacuum Sanitation System, Beijing, China: Sustainable Sanitation Alliance (SuSanA) URL [Accessed: 07.03.2011]

Alternative Versions to