Role Plays

Author/Compiled by

Sreevidya Satish (Ecosan Services Foundation)

Executive Summary

Role playing is a useful technique for developing a broad understanding of a situation or approach, and to prepare oneself for different eventualities. Role playing can be used to analyse problems from various perspectives, to spark brainstorming sessions, to experiment with different solutions to a problem, to develop team work, and help group problem-solving.

Advantages

Role playing can help to develop greater involvement with the issues and knowledge that is the focus of training (but it may not create greater involvement)

Role playing can be used as a behavioural pre-training assessment or diagnostic to assess where a learner is in terms of skills, since the trainer can observe real behaviour

Role playing also allows assessment of how well the learner understands and can apply what is learned, as indicated in their behaviour

Role playing provides opportunity to practice in what is presumably a safer environment where mistakes have no real world consequences as would be the case in on the job practice (Note that some learners will not find a role play environment safe)

Role playing practice can be segmented or divided up in ways that could not be done in real on the job settings. A person can practice a part of the actual skill to be learned until mastery, then another part of it and so on in progressively more complex steps. There can be a great deal of control over the practices

Because role plays can be involving, both in emotional and cognitive ways, they can also be used to help people understand others, and the positions of others. For example, a person can role play a position with which they disagree, to better understand that position

Disadvantages

The power of role playing is only harnessed when the role player receives expert feedback. Inexpert feedback or feedback from group members who are at the same level of competence as the role player is often useless, and does not further learning. Unfortunately, most role plays in training sessions are done in small groups, and most feedback given by other, less than competent group members

While trainers may like role plays, many people who attend training actually hate them and feel exceedingly uncomfortable in role play situations. This does not necessarily mean that people who hate them can not benefit by them, but trainers need to consider the tradeoffs between the use of role plays and the discomfort and anxiety they create

The role playing of highly emotionally charged situations tends to be less effective in large groups, since the role playing tends to take on the characteristic of acting performances, or, the performance becomes too artificial and sounds funny. It is hard, for example, for learners to pretend to be very angry without going over the top or starting to giggle. This is less of a concern in therapeutic settings, but is a factor in training

Almost every use of role-playing in large group training sessions involves extreme compromise, often to the extent that learning does not occur, or is interfered with. That is because role playing works best when there is sufficient time to prepare people for the role play, do the actual role play, provide expert feedback, and do any debriefs. Larger group sessions involve role-playing that goes basically "out of control" of the trainer, since the trainer can not monitoring constantly, or be the source of expert feedback

Introduction

A role play is a vivid way of learning how to handle different situations (KROEHNERT 2007). Role plays also effectively incorporate the principles of Adult Learning Theory. They can clearly show the relevance of the training and enable the trainees to apply the skills they are learning. Trainees share the learning experiences with each other in a supportive environment (BLANCHARD 2007). Furthermore, adults learn more effectively through participative techniques such as role plays.

Role play – a good and many-sided method of Instruction. Source: NAUKRIHUB (2007)

A role play is a simulation in which each participant is given a role to play. Trainees are given some information related to description of the role, concerns, objectives, responsibilities, emotions, etc. Then, a general description of the situation, and the problem that each one of them faces, is given. For instance, situation could be to propose a new water management system to the beverage industry, managing conflict, bringing different water users to talk to each other, etc. Once the participants read their role descriptions, they act out their roles by interacting with one another.

There are various types of role plays, such as:

Multiple role play – In this type of role play, all trainees are in groups, with each group acting out the role play simultaneously. After the role play, each group analyses the interactions and identifies the learning points.

Single role play – One group of participants plays the role for the rest, providing demonstrations of situation. Other participants observe the role play, analyse their interactions with one another and learn from the play.

Role rotation – It starts as a single role play. After the interaction of participants, the trainer will stop the role play and discuss what happened so far. Then the participants are asked to exchange characters. This method allows a variety of ways to approach the roles.

Spontaneous role play – In this kind of role play, one of the trainees plays herself while the other trainees play people with whom the first participant interacted before.

Purpose of Role Plays

A vivid role play in an ecosan course in India. Role plays are especially useful to round up a week of learning and force participants to put their acquired knowledge into practice. Furthermore, role plays can break monotonous lecture sessions as they are a lot of fun. Source: KROPAC 2007

A vivid role play in an ecosan course in India. Role plays are especially useful to round up a week of learning and force participants to put their acquired knowledge into practise. Furthermore, role plays can break monotonous lecture sessions as they are a lot of fun. Source: KROPAC (2007)

(Adapted from WOODROW n.y.)

Role plays are used to help examine real problems on the level of philosophy, emotional response, and physical response. Participants get a chance to analyse situations and try out different theories and tactics in a relatively safe setting. Role plays also enable trainees to understand different people and their roles and to develop insights into the thoughts and feelings of "opponents". Through role plays, participants can identify and anticipate possible problems and reveal fears and anxieties people have about an event or action. Role plays develop group and individual confidence and competence.

Steps in a Role play

(Adapted from WOODROW n.y.)

In the following, several steps to set up and perform a role play are described. Of course, the set up of role plays can vary.

Select a situation. Either (a) use a scenario developed by the trainers (see also handouts preparation), or (b) ask the participants to identify the problems they expect might occur or they fear will occur. If drawing scenarios from the group, one possible process is to ask participants to meet together in groups of three people for about five minutes to talk about the kinds of problem situations they think will come up. Then, call the participants back to the large group and ask someone from each group to call out situations "headline" style while you or a colleague write them up on newsprint. Once you have a list of situations, you as trainer pick a situation to start with usually a fairly simple scenario to get people warmed up and engaged. Save more complex or difficult problems until later in the session. Be sure to leave time to cover situations that were mentioned by several small groups.
Explain the situation: What groups/individuals are involved, what their roles are, what is the physical setting. If the scenario was drawn from the group, ask for the help of a participant who raised the situation to set the scene and players. Explain enough of background to make the situation clear, so roles will not be played solely from stereotypes. Since a role play is used to learn how to handle a particular situation, it is usually best to define carefully either the situation or the role to the players, but not both. Leave room for creative response by the participants.
Cast roles. Ask for volunteers among participants. If no one comes forward, ask specific people to play roles. If possible, cast people in roles with which they do not identify strongly. Ask role players to take fictitious names, whether they will be used or not.
Prepare the role players. Allow a few minutes for people to get into their roles and to plan their strategy in the role play. Ask people to think about other aspects of the character they are playing (job, family, motivation...) to make the roles realistic. If the role is unfamiliar, the trainer can help. Limit the time for this, however, in order to keep things moving and make sure the role play is spontaneous. If the trainer wants to give special or secret instructions to a role player, they can be given at this time.
Prepare the observers. Observation is as important as playing a role. Prepare observers by suggesting specific things they should watch for, such as the effects of different physical actions, words, gestures, tone, etc. Ask them not to say or do anything which might distract the role players. If the role play causes emotional reactions in participants, ask them to share their feelings early in the debriefing.
Set the scene. You establish the scene, the physical layout and any other relevant details.
Run the role play. Give a clear signal to begin the role play once the players are ready. Tell them from the start what signal you will use to stop the role play.
Cut the role play. Stop the role play when enough issues have been uncovered, or the action seems to come to an end, or when people want to stop. Keep the learning goals in mind when deciding. Stop the action if someone is about to get hurt, or the role play dissolves into laughter. If role players did not get "into" their roles, start again. If someone over-identifies with a role (indicated by showing great tension), stop and assist the person to step out of role.
Debrief. Debriefing allows people to examine what took place; it is essential for learning. Set a tone of exploration rather than judgement; draw the learning’s from the participants rather than provide answers yourself. Some trainers divide the evaluation into three sections: a) feelings, reactions, tensions; b) tactics, approaches, motivations/goals; c) general lessons or theoretical connexions. We recommend starting by asking the players how they felt in their roles. If practical, give each person a chance to speak.

Applicability

Role playing is when a group of people act out roles for a particular scenario. As an example, you might train water and sanitation experts by having two people act out a real scenario. One acts as the marketing person for sustainable sanitation. The other acts as the customer. This allows trainee people to practice their marketing techniques. A trainer and/or other trainees may watch the role play and critique it afterwards. Do not forget to plan time for this when designing the sessions.Role plays can be invaluable. They can also be a dreadful torment and waste of time. How you set them up and handle can often make the difference.

Media PPT

Training Methods

Library References